Recruiting 101: Where and How to Find the Best Instructors & Coaches

‍

If you're struggling to find great instructors or coaches, you're not alone. In today’s job market, it’s no longer enough to throw up a job ad and hope for the best. The best candidates? They're in high demand — and they’re looking for more than just a roster and a pay cheque.

‍

From standing out in a crowded market to refining your hiring process, we’re diving into the practical, proven strategies that turn recruitment from a headache into a competitive advantage. Let’s build a team that makes your business not just good — but unforgettable.

‍

What You're Really Hiring For

Most business owners make the mistake of leading with qualifications and experience when recruiting instructors. They create job descriptions that read like shopping lists of certifications and years of practice. But here's what actually predicts success in your classes: 

• The ability to connect with students at their level.
• The patience to explain the same concept five different ways until it clicks.
• The awareness to spot when someone's struggling and needs encouragement rather than correction.

These qualities can't be taught in certification courses. They're either present in someone's character or they're not.

‍

Now, this doesn't mean qualifications don't matter. Technical competence is absolutely essential. But it's the baseline, not the differentiator. The instructors who transform your business are those who understand that teaching is fundamentally about creating experiences that students want to repeat.

‍

Beyond the Job Boards

Traditional recruitment channels have become saturated and expensive. Every studio posts on Seek. Every school advertises on Indeed.

Smart operators are going where their ideal candidates actually spend time.

‍

University campuses represent untapped potential. Education students need practical experience. Sports science graduates want hands-on roles. Recent graduates in related fields often haven't considered teaching as a career path but possess exactly the analytical thinking and communication skills that make exceptional instructors.

‍

Community organisations offer another goldmine. Volunteer coaches at local clubs demonstrate commitment and passion. Retired teachers might welcome part-time opportunities that reconnect them with their love of instruction without the administrative burden of full-time employment.

‍

Your existing network holds more possibilities than you might realise. Current staff often know people with similar values and interests. Parents of your students sometimes have relevant backgrounds or connections.

‍

Social media platforms where professionals gather, particularly LinkedIn and industry-specific Facebook groups, allow you to identify potential candidates through their contributions and interests rather than just their job-seeking status.

‍

The Attraction Strategy

The best candidates aren't actively job hunting. They're doing work they enjoy, developing their skills, and building relationships in their current environments. To attract these people, you need to offer something more compelling than just employment.

• Professional development opportunities, such as the chance to attend workshops, pursue additional certifications, or learn from master teachers.
  ‍
• Flexible scheduling, like the ability to balance teaching with other pursuits or commitments attracts candidates who view your opportunity as part of a broader life design rather than just a job.
  ‍
• Compensation that reflects the value you place on quality instruction speaks volumes. This doesn't necessarily mean the highest hourly rate, but it does mean a package that demonstrates respect for professional teaching.

Show them you care about quality — not just with words, but with support, purpose, and fair pay that reflects their impact.

‍

The Interview Process That Works

Most interviews for teaching positions focus on the wrong things entirely. Asking about past experience tells you what someone has done, not how they think or how they'll perform in your specific environment.

Instead, create scenarios that reveal problem-solving ability and teaching instincts.

• "A new student joins your intermediate class but clearly has beginner-level skills. Walk me through how you'd handle the first lesson."
• "You notice a regular student seems frustrated and is considering quitting. What's your approach?"
• "A parent questions your teaching method and suggests a different technique they've heard about. How do you respond?"

These questions reveal judgment, communication skills, and professional confidence in ways that discussions about qualifications simply cannot. Practical demonstrations work even better than scenarios. Ask candidates to teach a short lesson to current staff members or willing volunteers.

‍

The candidates who excel in these practical situations often become your strongest instructors, regardless of their formal background.

‍

Build the Culture Great Instructors Want to Join

Top instructors don’t just want a job — they want to belong somewhere that respects their craft and helps them grow. If you want to attract (and keep) the best, start by creating a workplace they’re proud to be part of.

‍

Give them a voice in curriculum decisions. Recognise their expertise. Offer training, mentoring and room to develop professionally. Back it all with clear systems, open communication and regular feedback. The stuff that lets them focus on what they do best: teaching.

‍

And don’t underestimate the power of reputation. When your current team loves where they work, when ex-staff speak highly of you, when word gets around that you're the place to be, you stop chasing candidates. They come to you.

‍

This is how standout studios and schools hire: not out of desperation, but from a pool of people who already want in. Make culture your competitive edge  and watch the right instructors find you.