Hiring & Retaining High-Quality Instructors & Coaches

Ever had that moment when your star coach hands in their resignation right before your busiest season? Or when a parent pulls you aside to express concerns about inconsistent teaching quality across your different class locations?

‍

That sinking feeling when you realise your business success hangs on the skill and reliability of staff who often work part-time and may view their role as just a stepping stone.

‍

Let's take a peek at what's really happening here. The most successful class-based businesses aren't just good at finding talented instructors and coaches, they're exceptional at creating environments where those instructors want to stay, grow, and consistently deliver outstanding experiences.

‍

In this guide, we'll explore practical strategies for finding, developing, and keeping the kind of instructors and coaches who become the backbone of your business growth, not the source of your biggest headaches.

‍

Why Great Instructors Leave 

You know when you hire someone who seems perfect on paper, but they're gone within three months? Understanding these patterns is the first step toward building a more stable, high-performing team.

The top reasons exceptional instructors and coaches leave include:

• They don't see a clear path for growth or advancement.
• They feel undervalued compared to what they contribute.
• They lack proper support and resources to excel in their roles.
• The working culture feels transactional rather than meaningful.
• Their schedule is unpredictable or doesn't accommodate their other commitments.
• They don't feel connected to the larger purpose of your organisation.

Pro tip: Exit interviews aren't just for corporate settings. When instructors leave, have a candid conversation about their experience. The insights gained are often worth more than dozens of staff meetings.

‍

Finding Hidden Gems: Recruitment Strategies That Work

The traditional "post and pray" approach to hiring rarely brings exceptional talent through your door. Instead, try these targeted strategies:

‍

1. Look Beyond Traditional Credentials

The coach or instructor with the most certifications isn't always your best hire. Look for:

• People with complementary experience (competitive athletes, education students, camp counsellors).
• Individuals who demonstrate natural teaching ability and rapport with your demographic.
• Those with exceptional communication skills and emotional intelligence.
• Candidates who show genuine enthusiasm for your specific sport or activity.

Someone with less experience but extraordinary people skills can often outperform a highly qualified but less engaging instructor.

‍

2. Create a Talent Pipeline

Successful studios and schools don't just hire when they have an immediate need:

• Develop relationships with local university programs related to your field.
• Create junior instructor or assistant roles that allow promising individuals to learn your methodology.
• Offer workshops or training programs that can identify potential future staff.
• Implement a "refer an amazing instructor" bonus program for your existing team.
• Consider your advanced students or parent volunteers who already understand your culture.
  
  

3. Audit Your Hiring Process

Be honest: would you want to go through your own hiring process? If not, it's time for changes:

• Simplify your application process but add meaningful screening questions related to teaching philosophy.
• Include a practical demonstration component where candidates interact with your actual demographic.
• Have potential instructors observe your best classes before you make an offer.
• Involve your current star instructors in the interview process.
• Make sure your job postings emphasise what makes teaching at your organisation special, not just the responsibilities.

‍

Onboarding & Retention: The Keys to Instructor Stability

Did you know that 20% of new staff quits within the first 45 days due to inadequate onboarding? Make sure your newly hired talent has a great experience to ensure they stick around. 

‍

This could look like this: 

‍

Onboarding Essentials

• Run shadow sessions with top instructors across programs
• Provide clear teaching guides with context and "why"
• Schedule regular check-ins during the first 30 days
• Gradually increase responsibilities
• Assign a mentor and include in team activities
• Use a consistent onboarding checklist
  
  

Retention Must-Haves

• Offer growth plans and sponsor certifications
• Define advancement paths with clear goals
• Reward performance tied to student satisfaction
• Recognise excellence regularly and share wins
  
  

For Multi-Site Consistency

• Host regular all-team events or online forums
• Rotate senior staff to share best practices
• Appoint team leads aligned with your values
  
  

Supporting Young/Part-Time Staff

• Use flexible, predictable scheduling
• Provide simple visual teaching standards
• Run peer observations and short video reviews
• Define clear metrics for a successful class

Pro tip: Document your onboarding process with a simple checklist to ensure nothing falls through the cracks, especially when you're onboarding multiple instructors simultaneously or across different locations.

‍

Your Next Steps

Building a strong instructor team isn't about finding unicorns who arrive perfect on day one. It's about creating an environment where passionate people can develop into exceptional educators who see your business as a meaningful part of their professional journey.

‍

Start by honestly assessing your current approach: 

• How structured is your hiring process?
• What does the first month look like for a new instructor?
• What growth opportunities exist for someone who's been with you for a year?
• How do you recognise and reward excellence in teaching?
• What regular touchpoints exist between management and instructors?

Remember that your instructors and coaches aren't just service providers, they're the living embodiment of your brand in every class. When you invest in their success, you're investing directly in your business's future.

‍

Because at the end of the day, people don't leave good jobs. They leave environments where they don't feel valued, supported, or inspired.

‍